Not sure if this is a bug or a lack of clarification, but the achievement doesn't seem to be functioning. I popped all bad earthlings multiple times in one run and didn't get it, but this might have been because some of them were killed with the bowling ball and the opera singer. If the achievement requires purely tomatoes, or only the thrown type of tomatoes, it should be listed in the achievement's description.
Ps4 trophy just pooped for me. Either its fixed, or i got lucky.
I also did my own attempt at this and did not get rewarded the achiev. Murdered everyone I could, good, neutral or bad. We managed to kill everything, Santa and Elf died to an opera singer, the rest with tomatoes, murdered all backers, also ran through a list, popped with tomato/rain, popped even the drones individually, popped tornado with an amped tomato rain aftr quite a few hits (or I think it popped, it gives a different poof effect with sand on it but it might just have disappeared? Not sure)
Run was done online, 2 players (3 for a part of it), random world hard mode.
Did some testing, and still did not get the achievement. During the run I:
-Kept a list of every bad and neutral earthling from the manual to make sure I didn't miss any
- Popped every grounded bad earthling with either Tomatoes or the Slingshot, including those with more than one type
- Possibly did NOT pop the drones themselves (popped both Marvin and Floyd)
- Popped both Cupid types with Tomato Rain
- Popped the neutral earthlings with Tomatoes or the Slingshot, with the exception of the Tornado, which had too high a health pool and had to be killed with two Funk-Fu blasts
- Popped some of the good earthlings, not sure if I popped all of them (Santa most likely left over)
- Popped a backer
- Completed the run without saving and quitting
- Completed the run on Random World, on a normal difficulty Latisha
Was really hoping my problem was that I didn't use Tomatoes for every pop, but unfortunately that doesn't seem to be the case. Unless the issue is a lack of good earthling pops, this is most likely a bug.
did you pop any good earthling as well? I know opera singer can pop santa and sushi man, I popped an elf once with funk fu, I just tried one of these but my brother accidently hit the last ship piece before I could kill the clipboard lady, the last earthling I had left, so I can't confirm it works. But we also popped all the backers. Very interested to know if I just wasted a bunch of time XD
@Officer Dk: I think I popped all of them the first time around, but I didn't pop any backers. Didn't make a difference, unfortunately.